Question: Is A 357 Magnum More Powerful Than A 40 Caliber?

Is a 357 good for self defense?

357 Magnum really isn’t good for self defense, and especially home defense, because it is very flashy, has a lot of recoil, and a LOT of noise indoors at night..

Will a 45 kill a bear?

45 caliber pistols against bears. All were successful. One was against a black bear, which was killed with additional shots, probably from another handgun. … The grizzly bear was killed with one shot.

Will a 40 cal kill you?

40 caliber can wound, injure, incapacitate, or kill. However, shot placement is the best predictor of accomplishing the intended goals. I have treated patients with more than 20 “holes” in them that never caused enough tissue damage or bleeding to cause them to die. … 40 S&W modern hollow-point ammunition as well as .

Is a 45 caliber More powerful than a 357?

357 Magnum cartridge is individually more powerful than an individual . 45 ACP cartridge, all else being equal, a . 45 ACP pistol will be a (marginally) more powerful tool than a . 357 Magnum revolver in the vast majority of cases where the individual power of the cartridge is not an issue (vs.

Is a 9mm more powerful than a 40 cal?

The 9mm has a muzzle energy of 364 ft-lbs, while the . 40 S&W has a muzzle energy of 484 ft-lbs. This is one comparison, but you will generally find that most . 40 S&W products are stronger both at the muzzle and downrange.

Will a 357 kill a bear?

For a bear cartridge anything equal to or more powerful than a . 41 Magnum or . 44 Magnum will be fine. … 357 Magnum or other similar-caliber load, a well-placed shot with a good bullet will certainly kill a bear, but it’s not recommended.

Does a .357 have stopping power?

So for the . 357 Magnum, its era of legendary stopping power is over. Unless you’re going hunting, in which case by all means continue.

What is the deadliest handgun caliber?

9mmDespite its age, the 9mm is more dangerous than ever before, due to innovations in ammunition lethality that squeeze greater performance out of the bullet.

Whats stronger a .44 or 357?

The .357 is categorically less powerful in terms of available foot-pounds and bullet mass. But the .44 is almost too much to handle when it comes to the same two criteria. Given a similar gun and barrel length, the .357 will always be easier to shoot and generally more accurate.

Can a 40 S&W stop a bear?

Yes a . 40 cal can kill and stop a bear, any bear. … We use buffalo rounds designed for deep penetration on big animals, like a bear. Situation awareness is important but if a bear has made its mine up to attack you generally you are in no position to get a good shot.

What is the best caliber gun for self defense?

The 3 Best Handgun Calibers for Armed Self-Defense9mm. Gun gurus once considered 9mm Luger ammunition to be underpowered, best for shooters who couldn’t or wouldn’t “man-up” and shoot the big boy . 45 ACP caliber cartridge. … 2. . 38 Special. … 10mm. Let’s say recoil isn’t an issue.

Why is 40 hated?

40 s&w which is basically just a lighter 10mm. The result is that you get a round with a more snappy recoil than a 9mm by with no real advantage. … It’s already been said but people just hate it because it is more expensive than 9mm and not any better.

Is 40 S&W good for self defense?

The . 40 S&W is a perfectly viable self-defense round. … But, if you shoot a lot and want to shoot better for less money, or if you’re considering using a handgun for personal or home defense, pick up a 9mm handgun and get shooting. You’ll save time and money, without compromising defensive performance.

Is a 357 more powerful than a 9mm?

357 Magnum has higher velocities and generally packs heavier bullets, it inevitably has greater muzzle energy, both at the muzzle and downrange. Sticking with the two Federal Hydra-Shok products, we see that the 124-gr 9mm rounds deliver a muzzle energy of 345 foot-pounds (ft-lbs).

Why do cops use 40?

Less recoil, cheaper ammo, higher capacity — there are a lot of reasons why law enforcement officers are going back to the 9mm!

What is the difference between a 357 and a 40 caliber?

357 Sig is a flatter shooting cartridge than the . 40 S&W. … 357 Sig has more accuracy at longer ranges. It also retains energy at those longer ranges so it hits harder at 100 yards than the 9mm does at the muzzle.

What has more stopping power 40 or 45?

Wow- to actually answer your question, if both have properly designed bullets, the . 40 has more stopping power.

Do 40 cal pistols wear out faster?

Most guns chambered in the . 40s&w were designed for the 9mm, but with a wider chamber and hole through the barrel. … 40s&w also tend to wear out faster than their 9mm siblings, so that’s a wash. (The thinner barrel steel was one reason no manufacturer ever tried to sell higher-pressure ammo in caliber .